←Go back to RSPCA

RSPCA Australia knowledgebase

RSPCA Australia Knowledgebase

Search:     Advanced search

Can the RSPCA prosecute farmers for performing painful husbandry procedures without anaesthetic or pain relief?

Article ID: 84
Last updated: 25 Nov, 2008
Revision: 1
print  Print
share  Share
Views: 18957

The RSPCA can only prosecute farmers for cruelty if they have broken laws relating to animal welfare that apply in their state or territory. If farmers are operating within the law, the RSPCA inspectors who enforce animal protection legislation cannot prosecute them.

Under most state and territory legislation relating to animal welfare, it is an offence to cause an animal unnecessary pain; however, farm animals are often exempt from such legislation. Some surgical procedures may only be undertaken by veterinary surgeons, but others may be undertaken by nonveterinary (lay) people working on farms provided that they follow accepted husbandry practices. These accepted practices are set out in the Australian model codes of practice for the welfare of animals (http://www.publish.csiro.au/nid/22/sid/11.htm), which set minimum guidelines for people involved in livestock production.

The model codes may recommend that anaesthetic or pain relief be used for certain procedures, but because these recommendations are not mandatory they are not enforceable. In some states and territories, the model codes have been referenced into the law, which means they can be used as a defence in a cruelty prosecution. In other words, demonstrated compliance with a particular model code can see a cruelty charge dropped.

The RSPCA would be able to prosecute in cases involving individual animals if husbandry procedures were undertaken in a way that clearly contravened the relevant model code.

This article was:  

Also read
folder Why are painful procedures performed without anaesthetic?
folder What is mulesing and what are the alternatives?
folder Why are cattle dehorned and is it painful?
folder Why are the tails of dairy cows docked?
folder Is dehorning of cattle legal?
folder Why are many male farm animals castrated?
folder Why do farmed deer have their antlers removed?
folder Why are cattle spayed?
folder What is boar taint and how can it be prevented?
folder What are the welfare issues with tail biting and tail docking in pigs?

Also listed in
folder Farm animals -> Animal management
folder Farm animals -> Cattle
folder Farm animals -> Chickens
folder Farm animals -> Pigs
folder Farm animals -> Sheep

Prev     Next
Animal husbandry       How are beef cattle reared?